BW vs Color, Decisions

When it comes to developing certain frames sometimes I’m not sure whether to go BW or Color. So here’s another exercise in processing. Personally, I like both of course, but my heart is usually on the BW. What do you think? To give you guys a perspective on how I did these. First, I went through Lightroom 3 and did some basic adjustments. What adjustments?

Canon, 40D, Wedding Photography, Event Photography, Sigma 24-60mm, 2.8 EX DG
Isabel, Coral Gables ― Canon 40D, Sigma 24-60mm 2.8 EX DG

1. The first thing I do is adjust White Balance. A funky WB will give you different looks which may not necessarily be wrong but certain looks have certain looks as they say.
2. Adjust the black, I usually bump up a little bit of clarity and vibrance, and then set a tone curve.
3. Usually, I stop at step 2 but for these I hop on over to my Photoshop replacement app called Pixelmator(Mac Only) and did some basic retouching. My goal with retouching is always to have the subject look as natural as possible. Yes, that’s really her. She’s a beauty.

Canon, 40D, Wedding Photography, Event Photography, Sigma 24-60mm, 2.8 EX DG
Isabel, Coral Gables ― Canon 40D, Sigma 24-60mm 2.8 EX DG

So, tough choices sometimes but in the end one must make a decision and live it.

6 thoughts on “BW vs Color, Decisions

  1. I like the BW better for this image, draws more attention to her face and smile. I see it at the lab where I work all the time, when you flip an image from color to BW the focal point changes. That being said, for my personal images I have a hard time seeing the BW potential. I guess it’s a matter of practice.

  2. Hello, Jorge. Don’t I know this dilemma…! My approach usually is: “a photo is always better in black and white until proven otherwise…” This is tough case to choose b&w because the background is complex and distractive and the color version has same amount of cold/warm contrast that helps differentiate the subject from the background. For the b&w version I would try to add some vignette to darken the edges and direct more attention to Isabel. Cheers!

  3. I’ve always been a B&W shooter. This photo is color to me.
    The leaves on the foreground and background seem to be on the same plane due to the tonal range/contrast.

    The color seperates the background from the foreground with different shades of green. This effect now wraps around her and creates a feeling of dimension. Because of that, her face sculpts better in the light and tones.

Thoughts? Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: